How to price a product: find three numbers, then test between them

Price a product from three numbers: your cost floor, the buyer's alternatives and the value you create. Then test a range with buyer interviews and adjust.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 5 min read

To price a product, find three numbers and test between them: the lowest price that covers your costs, what the buyer's current alternatives cost, and the value the product creates for them. Your first price usually sits above the cost floor, near or above the alternatives, and well below the full value. Buyer interviews tell you where in that range to start. Your first sales tell you whether you were right. (For the broader choice of strategy, see pricing strategy.)

The example: an inventory app for restaurants

Here is a made-up example: an inventory-counting app for independent restaurants, sold per location per month. Every number below is invented to show the arithmetic.

1. Set a cost floor from the cost to serve, not to build

List what one customer costs you for a month. Stripe's pricing guide suggests including materials, labor, support, shipping and overhead, and checking that subscription customers pay back their acquisition and support costs over time.

For the app:

  • Hosting and data: $12 per location per month.
  • Support: about one hour per location per month at a loaded $30 an hour, so $30.
  • Cost to serve: $12 + $30 = $42 per location per month.

Then check acquisition payback. If winning a location costs about $600 in sales and marketing, months to earn it back are $600 divided by the monthly margin:

  • At $79: $600 / ($79 - $42) = $600 / $37, about 16 months.
  • At $129: $600 / ($129 - $42) = $600 / $87, about 7 months.

So the real floor is above $42: the lowest price at which payback fits your cash plan.

2. Price against what buyers would do instead (including nothing)

Doing nothing is always one of the buyer's alternatives. Stripe notes that competitor pricing helps anchor your range but should not dictate your decision.

For a restaurant, the alternatives might be a manager counting stock on a clipboard and typing it into a spreadsheet, a feature inside their point-of-sale system, or a dedicated inventory tool. (The clipboard is free, which is a hard price to beat.) Suppose the dedicated tools owners mention in interviews cost roughly $80 to $150 per location per month. That is your reference band. Note where each number came from: a price an owner remembers is weaker evidence than an invoice.

3. Estimate the value, counting only what you can support

Value is what changes for the customer. Stripe's example: a product that saves someone $10,000 a year "might be a bargain at $2,000."

Suppose managers say counting takes about four hours a week and the app would cut that to one. That saves 3 hours x 52 weeks / 12 months = 13 hours a month. At a manager's loaded cost of $25 an hour, that is 13 x $25 = $325 a month per location.

Two cautions. Time saved only counts if the owner uses it for something else, so ask. And leave out benefits like less food waste until interviews support them.

4. Test a range between the floor and the value

Side by side:

InputMonthly amount per location
Cost to serve$42
Price for about 7-month payback$129
Alternatives$80 to $150
Estimated value$325

A reasonable test range is $99 to $149. At $129 the customer keeps about $196 of the estimated $325, and you sit inside the band they already compare against.

5. Show each buyer one concrete offer

Start with what already happened, as GOV.UK's interview guidance recommends, then move to a concrete offer.

  • "Walk me through the last stock count. Who did it, how long did it take, and what went wrong?"
  • "What do you use now, and what does it cost you, including staff time?"
  • "Who decides on a new tool like this: you, a partner, a head chef?"
  • "Here is the offer: counts by phone, weekly variance report, $129 per location per month, cancel any time. What would you need to see before trying it?"

Listen for comparisons ("that's more than our POS add-on") and for who else must agree. Ask the price question once per person, about one offer; change it mid-conversation and the interview turns into a haggle. How to research willingness to pay covers turning this into a commitment test, and willingness to pay compares survey methods if you need a larger sample.

People who see many restaurant purchases, such as sales professionals in restaurants and procurement professionals in restaurants, can tell you how groups usually buy software and what they push back on.

6. Launch, then watch the signals you chose

Stripe recommends treating the launch price as a working hypothesis. Track:

  • Win rate at each price if you offer different prices to different prospects.
  • How often you discount, and by how much. Frequent discounting means the list price is not the real price.
  • Objections in lost deals, in the buyer's words (how to interview lost deals).
  • Payback against the target you set in step 1.

Decide in advance what would make you change the price, for example: "if fewer than one in five qualified trials convert at $129, test $99."

Your next step

Fill in the table with your own numbers, mark the guesses, and plan interviews to replace them. If you need owners, managers or buyers outside your network, search on Instant Expert. It finds people whose work matches your question and sends your invitations, and you pay for each call that gets booked. Pricing research lists more questions by method.

Six steps to a first price

  1. 1

    Cost floor

    Add up the monthly cost to serve one customer and check acquisition payback.

  2. 2

    Alternatives

    List what buyers would do instead and what each option costs them.

  3. 3

    Value

    Estimate what changes for the customer, counting only benefits you can support.

  4. 4

    Test range

    Pick two or three prices between the floor and the value, near the alternatives.

  5. 5

    Buyer interviews

    Ask about recent events, then show one concrete offer and record the reaction.

  6. 6

    Launch and watch

    Track win rate, discounting, objections and payback, with a rule for changing price.

Costs set the floor, value sets the ceiling, and alternatives and interviews decide where to start between them.