Willingness to pay: treat every survey answer as a ceiling
Willingness to pay from a survey runs high. Compare direct questions, Van Westendorp, conjoint and real offers, and the bias in each, before you set a price.
Treat any willingness to pay number from a survey as a ceiling until someone takes a real buying step. Willingness to pay (WTP) is the highest price a particular buyer would pay for a particular offer, given their alternatives. Every way of measuring it short of a real purchase produces a stated number, and stated numbers tend to run high.
For the interview approach, see how to research willingness to pay without asking for a guess.
People say they will pay more than they do
Researchers call that gap "hypothetical bias." A 2020 meta-analysis by Schmidt and Bijmolt in the Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science pooled 77 studies from 47 papers, with 115 effect sizes (read the abstract). It found:
- An average hypothetical bias of 21%, with stated WTP above real WTP.
- Indirect methods such as conjoint analysis overestimated real WTP more than direct questions did, which the authors note runs against conventional wisdom.
- Larger bias for higher-valued products, specialty goods, and designs where the same person answers about several prices.
Two cautions: the studies covered consumer goods, and an average is not a correction factor for your market.
A 2011 study by Miller, Hofstetter, Krohmer and Zhang in the Journal of Marketing Research compared open-ended questions, choice-based conjoint and two incentive-aligned methods against real purchases. The incentive-aligned methods passed the authors' statistical and decision tests, but biased hypothetical methods could still point to the right pricing decision (read the abstract). A biased number can still point to the right price; distrust the absolute level more.
Each method has its own blind spot
| Method | What you ask | Main bias or blind spot |
|---|---|---|
| Open-ended question | "What is the most you would pay?" | Guesswork; people may anchor on a price they saw recently or answer low to influence yours |
| Gabor-Granger | "Would you buy at $X?" moving up after a yes, down after a no | One product in isolation; Sawtooth notes it is "so clearly a pricing game" that answers may not predict purchases |
| Van Westendorp | Four thresholds from too cheap to too expensive | Measures perception, not choice; no competitors in view |
| Monadic test | Each group sees one price, often next to competitors and a "none" option | Needs larger samples, one concept at a time |
| Conjoint analysis | Choose between bundles of features and prices | Still hypothetical; the meta-analysis above found indirect methods overestimated more |
| Incentive-aligned bid (BDM) | State a bid; a random price is drawn and the person buys if the bid is at least that price | Hard to run for B2B products that need contracts and approvals |
| Past-purchase interview | Walk through the last time they paid for a comparable fix | Small samples; the person may not know the full budget |
| Real offer or paid pilot | A specific price for a specific scope | Narrow: tells you about this buyer and this offer only |
Sources for the survey methods: Sawtooth on pricing research methods, Sawtooth on Gabor-Granger and Sawtooth on Van Westendorp. For a step-by-step Van Westendorp analysis, see the Van Westendorp guide.
A made-up example: what to do with a $150 answer
Say you sell a scheduling tool to dental practices and survey 40 office managers. The median answer to "What is the most you would pay per month?" is $150.
Don't divide by 1.21 and call it your real WTP. The 21% is a consumer-study average, not a property of dental office managers. The arithmetic ($150 / 1.21 ≈ $124) only shows how much a bias that size would matter.
Ask who answered. An office manager may run the schedule but not sign the contract. If the dentist-owner or a group's operations lead approves software, their view of the price matters more. See how to interview users, buyers and champions.
Turn the number into two prices to test. Offer $99 and $149 per month to different practices through the normal sales process. Record what each does next: requests a proposal, books a demo with the owner, or signs a pilot. Those actions are closer to real WTP than any survey answer.
Five ways to shrink the bias in any method
- Describe a concrete offer. "A tool that fills cancelled appointments from your waitlist, $149 per practice per month, cancel any time" gets a better answer than "a scheduling tool."
- Put alternatives in view. Name the current workaround and any competing product.
- Show each person one price when you can. The meta-analysis found larger bias when the same person evaluated several prices.
- Ask about the past first. What they last paid for a comparable fix grounds the later price questions. GOV.UK's interview guidance recommends stories and real examples over generalities.
- Record who controls the budget. Mark each answer as from a user, an influencer or the approver.
In B2B, the company decides what it will pay
In B2B, WTP depends on budget cycles, procurement rules and whether the spend replaces an existing line item. A manager can mean it when they say $150 is fine and still be unable to buy this quarter.
So pair a small survey with interviews of people who see many buying decisions: procurement leads, former salespeople in the category, or consultants who implement similar tools. They know what a normal budget line looks like and who signs it. Pricing research shows how to combine these methods in one study.
Next step
Pick the method from the table that fits your stage, then plan a real buying step to check it. If you need office managers, owners or procurement people in dental services to talk to, search on Instant Expert and describe their role.
The invitation runs a small willingness-to-pay test of its own, from the other side. Each person comes with a suggested price. You can offer more, or as low as a quarter of it (or $40, if that's less), and never under $5. If your offer is too low, the person can reply with the price they want, and you decide whether to accept. Our fee is added on top of whatever they receive (a $100 offer costs you $125), and you're charged only if they book or answer. A dental office manager's counteroffer tells you what their time is worth to them. It says nothing about what their practice would pay for your product, so keep the two numbers apart.