Competitive analysis template: a copyable matrix, filled in for you

A copyable competitive analysis template and competitive matrix, with a filled example and rows that keep competitor claims apart from what buyers told you.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 7 min read

A competitive analysis template is a table with one column for each option your buyers could choose instead of you, and one row for each question you need answered about those options. Copy the blank competitive matrix template below, then look at the filled example.

The version worth using keeps what competitors say about themselves (public sources) apart from what buyers told you (interviews), and records where and when each answer came from. Skip that, and the matrix turns into a tidy summary of your competitors' marketing. For the full method, see competitor analysis. This page is the worksheet.

The blank competitive matrix template

Put the options across the top, including at least one that is not a product (a spreadsheet, a hire, doing nothing), because buyers often choose it. Rows 1 to 7 come from public material. Rows 8 to 12 come from conversations.

RowQuestionWhere the answer comes fromOption AOption BCurrent workaround
1Type: direct, indirect or workaroundBuyer interviews, your judgment
2Who they sell to (segment, size, region)Website, case studies, job posts
3What they claim, in their wordsHomepage, ads, sales decks you received as a buyer
4Price and packagingPricing page, quotes you received
5What the product does and does not doHelp docs, changelog, free trial
6How important your target market is to themCase studies, hiring, annual report
7Barriers to switching or enteringContracts, integrations, buyer interviews
8Why buyers chose itInterviews with people who chose it
9Where buyers say it falls shortInterviews with users and people who left
10What switching away would cost a buyerInterviews with buyers
11Who decides and who uses itInterviews with buyers
12Evidence count and last checkedYour notes

Rows 2, 6 and 7 follow the SBA's competitive analysis checklist, which suggests identifying competitors by product line and market segment, and assessing how important your target market is to each competitor, barriers to entry, and indirect or secondary competitors. The SBA also lists in-depth interviews as a direct research method. Those go in rows 8 to 11.

A filled example: reorder software for vet clinics

Here is a made-up example. Say you are building software that tracks drug and supply stock at independent veterinary clinics and drafts reorders. Option A is a practice-management suite with an inventory module. Option B is a distributor's free ordering portal. The workaround is a shared spreadsheet plus the practice manager's memory. You interviewed six practice managers, two per option. Everything here is hypothetical.

RowQuestionOption A: practice suite moduleOption B: distributor portalWorkaround: spreadsheet
1TypeDirectIndirectWorkaround
2Who they sell toMulti-location groups (case studies, job posts)Every clinic that buys from that distributorAnyone
3What they claim"One system for the whole practice""Order in two clicks"Nothing to buy
4Price and packagingNot published; module sold with the suiteFree with purchasesStaff time
5What it does and does not doTracks stock; no reorder suggestions (help docs)Reorders from one distributor onlyWhatever the manager maintains
6Importance of your market to themLow: marketing aimed at groupsHigh: clinics are their customersNot applicable
7Switching barriersReplacing the suite is a large projectNone for the clinicNone
8Why buyers chose itCame with the suite (2 of 2)Free and already in use (2 of 2)"We never had time to set anything up" (2 of 2)
9Where it falls shortCounts drift because staff skip scanning (2 of 2)Cannot compare prices across distributors (1 of 2)Stockouts of controlled drugs noticed late (2 of 2)
10Switching costOnly the module is needed; suite staysNoneAn afternoon of setup
11Who decides, who usesOwner decides; manager usesManager decides and usesManager
12Evidence and last checkedDocs, 2 interviews, Sep 30Portal, 2 interviews, Sep 302 interviews, Sep 30

Read across a row to compare. Read down a column to summarize one option.

The pattern here: the spreadsheet clinics and the suite clinics share one problem, stock records they cannot trust. The portal is a free habit you would sit next to, not replace. So sell to managers who already feel the counting problem, and make the product work alongside the portal. Two interviews per option is enough to form that view, not to settle it.

How to fill the rows

For the public rows, copy claims in the competitor's own words with the page and date (a claim is what they want buyers to believe, not proof). Many B2B products do not publish prices, so write "not published" instead of guessing. For row 6, read a public competitor's annual report: Investor.gov's guide to reading a 10-K explains that Item 1 describes the business and may cover competition, and Item 1A lists the most significant risks. Private competitors generally do not file these, so use case studies and job posts and label the answer an inference.

No amount of searching fills rows 8 to 11. Talk to customers who picked you over each option, prospects who picked it over you and customers who left you for it. Ask them to walk through the decision in order: what started the search, which options they looked at, who was involved and what settled it. How to interview customers who chose another product covers these calls.

Say who you are at the start of every interview. The SCIP Code of Ethics asks competitive intelligence practitioners to disclose their identity and organization before all interviews, and to tell a competitor's former employees up front that you do not want confidential information. Competitive intelligence covers where those lines sit.

Write the count next to each finding, as in "2 of 2". It stops one vivid quote from becoming a conclusion.

Three ways to make the matrix lie to you

  • Leaving out the workaround column. If most buyers still use a spreadsheet, the spreadsheet is your main competitor. (It has no sales team and still wins.)
  • Scoring without definitions. A 1 to 5 score for "ease of use" means little unless you define a 1 and a 5 and note who gave the score.
  • Letting it go stale. Row 12 shows which columns are out of date. Refresh the interview rows when lost deals start sounding different.

Your next step

Copy the blank template, fill the columns with the options your last five buyers considered and complete rows 1 to 7. Then book three conversations with people who chose the option you lose to most.

If those people are outside your network, describe them on Instant Expert, such as "practice managers at independent veterinary clinics," or start from the directory pages for operations professionals in veterinary services and sales professionals in veterinary services. For the three conversations, say you offer $100 each for a 30-minute call: with our fee on top (20% of what you pay), each booked call costs you $125, so the most the three can cost is $375 (how it works). Use the note to do what the SCIP code asks: say who you are and which company you work for, and that you don't want confidential information. Each person has 7 days to book or decline, and declines cost nothing.

If you're invited to talk about a product you chose

A buyer asking why you picked another option wants your decision, not your employer's secrets. Answer from your own experience and keep confidential information out of it, the same line you would hold when speaking at a conference. The invitation shows the sender's note and the amount you would receive, which is yours in full; you can take the call, send a written or voice answer instead, or decline. Payment goes out 24 hours after the call.