Market research methodologies: pick the question first, then the method
Market research methodologies compared: what each method answers, where it fails, and a made-up refill program that uses four of them to make one decision.
Market research methodologies come down to two choices. You either collect new information yourself (primary research) or use what someone already collected (secondary research), and you either explain why something happens (qualitative) or count how often it happens (quantitative). Write your question down first, then pick the method that answers it.
Most useful research mixes a few methods. A reason needs a conversation. A count needs a survey or a dataset.
Start with secondary research, because it is usually cheaper
The SBA's market research guide recommends existing sources for general, countable questions like industry trends, demographics and household incomes, and direct research for questions about your own business or customers. It lists free federal sources, including Census, Bureau of Labor Statistics and Bureau of Economic Analysis data.
Secondary research has two gaps. It is rarely about your exact customers, and it says what happened without saying why. Primary research fills both, at the cost of time and often money.
Qualitative explains why. Quantitative counts how many.
Nielsen Norman Group's overview of research methods says qualitative methods suit questions about why or how to fix a problem, and quantitative methods do better with how many and how much. In qualitative work you hear from people directly and can ask follow-ups. In quantitative work a survey or analytics tool collects the data and you analyze it mathematically.
The same article adds a second split: what people say versus what they do. Interviews and surveys capture what people report. Experiments, analytics and sales data capture what they did. The two often differ. (Ask a room how often they go to the gym, then check the gym's door counter.)
The main methods and what each is for
| Method | Type | Best for | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Public data and industry reports | Secondary, quantitative | Market size, trends, number of businesses | Rarely about your customers; no reasons |
| In-depth interviews | Primary, qualitative | Why people buy, switch or give up | Can't tell you how common something is |
| Expert or industry interviews | Primary, qualitative | How an industry buys, prices and operates | Their view of customers is secondhand |
| Focus groups | Primary, qualitative | Group reactions to a brand or concept | The group shapes the answers |
| Surveys | Primary, quantitative | How common a view or behavior is | Only as good as the sample and wording |
| Observation and field visits | Primary, qualitative | The real process, including forgotten steps | Slow; your presence changes behavior |
| Experiments and pilots | Primary, quantitative | Whether people buy, click or sign up | Needs enough traffic to read results |
| Your own sales and product data | Secondary to you, quantitative | What existing customers actually do | Silent on people who never became customers |
NN/g describes focus groups as sessions of 3 to 12 participants that give a top-of-mind view of a brand or concept, and notes they are less useful for usability questions. Before you write a survey, AAPOR's best practices ask whether a survey is the right method at all and whether existing data already answers the question. They also recommend pretesting the questions with people like your respondents.
A worked example: one refill program, four methods
Here is a made-up example. You run a small skincare brand and are deciding whether to launch a refill program.
- Secondary research. Look up any rules on refillable cosmetic packaging where you sell, and check what similar brands offer.
- Interviews. Ask six to eight current customers about the last time they ran out of a product and what they did. You learn whether refills fix a real annoyance or only sound nice. Also talk to someone who has run packaging or operations for a beauty brand about costs and returns logistics. The beauty and personal care product professionals directory page is one place to start.
- Survey. If the interviews point to a clear reason, survey your customer list to estimate how many share it.
- Pilot. Offer one product with a refill option on your site and see who pays.
The interviews found the reason, the survey sized it and the pilot tested behavior.
How to pick a method
Write the question in one sentence, then ask:
- Has someone already collected this? Use secondary research.
- Do I need to understand a reason or a process? Use interviews.
- Do I need to know how common something is? Use a survey with a sample that matches the people you care about.
- Do I need to know whether people will act? Use a pilot.
Interviews versus surveys goes deeper on the most common choice, and combining interviews with product data covers using methods together.
When the method you need is a conversation with someone outside your network, describe the person on Instant Expert, such as "operations managers at beauty brands who set up a refill or returns program," or paste the LinkedIn URLs of people you already have in mind. You review who it finds, set what each person receives and choose the format: a 15, 30, 45 or 60 minute call, or a written or voice answer to one question. Our fee (20% of what you pay) is added on top, so a $100 offer costs you $125, charged only if they book or answer.
Match the format to the method. An interview about why customers switch needs a call, because the follow-ups carry it. A single factual question from step 2, such as how returned packaging is usually collected and cleaned, can be a written answer the person sends on their own time. Either way they have 7 days to respond, and declines cost nothing.