Competitor analysis: the rival you most need to beat might be a spreadsheet

A competitor analysis lists what buyers could choose instead of you and why: public facts, buyers who compared, and former staff who keep their secrets.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 6 min read

A competitor analysis lists the options your buyers could choose instead of you and explains why buyers pick each one. Those include direct rivals, indirect ones and doing the job another way, such as a spreadsheet or an extra hire. The spreadsheet is often the one you most need to beat.

Public material shows what competitors claim. Buyers who compared or switched explain why they chose. Former staff of a competitor can explain how the market works, if you don't ask for confidential information.

The example: scheduling software for cleaning companies

Here is a made-up example, used throughout. You are building software that schedules crews and tracks site visits for commercial cleaning companies. Two established software products sell to the same companies, and many smaller firms run everything on spreadsheets and group texts. You want to know where you can win before you set prices and pick the first features.

1. Let buyers tell you who the competitors are

The SBA's guide to market research and competitive analysis suggests identifying competitors by product line and market segment, then assessing their market share, strengths and weaknesses, how important your target market is to them, barriers to entry, and indirect or secondary competitors.

Your own list is usually incomplete. Ask five or six recent buyers, including some who didn't choose you: "What else did you look at, and what were you doing before?" In the example, answers might include the two software products, a general-purpose scheduling app and "our office manager handles it in a spreadsheet."

2. Collect what competitors publish, with dates

Record where each fact came from and when you saw it:

What to recordWhere to find itWhat to watch for
Who they sell to and what they claimWebsite, case studies, adsClaims are marketing, not evidence
Prices and packagingPricing page, sales quotes you received as a buyerMany B2B products show no prices; list prices differ from what customers pay
What the product doesHelp docs, changelog, free trialDocs show features, not how well they work
Where they are investingJob postings, press releasesA hiring push is a hint, not a plan
What customers complain aboutPublic reviews, forumsReviewers are a self-selected group
Business, risks and competitionAnnual reports of public companiesPrivate competitors generally do not file them

For a public competitor, read the annual report on Form 10-K. Investor.gov's guide to reading a 10-K explains that Item 1 describes the business and may cover its competition, Item 1A lists the most significant risks, and the management discussion gives the company's own view of its results. 10-Ks are public on the SEC's EDGAR website. Patents are public records too, and SCIP's ethics guidance treats reviewing them as expected.

3. Ask buyers why they chose, because websites can't tell you

Interview three groups: customers who chose you over a competitor, prospects who chose a competitor, and customers who left you for one.

Ask them to walk through the decision in order, from what started the search to what settled it. Ask what the competitor did well. Buyers are often more specific about a competitor's strengths than about yours (this stings, and it is useful). How to interview customers who chose another product and how to interview churned customers cover these conversations.

Talk to people who run the work as well as people who bought software. An operations manager at a cleaning company can explain which scheduling problems cost them money, whichever tool they use.

4. Talk to former employees, and say up front what you won't ask

Former sales and support staff at a competitor know how buyers evaluate vendors and where rollouts go wrong. They also owe duties to their former employer.

The SCIP Code of Ethics, which SCIP describes as the most widely embraced set of ethics guidelines for competitive and market intelligence work, gives practical rules:

  • Say who you are. Disclose your identity and organization before every interview. Don't pretend to be a customer, recruiter or anyone else; SCIP notes that kind of misrepresentation may be illegal depending on the jurisdiction.
  • Tell former employees up front that you don't want confidential information. SCIP says they owe a duty of confidentiality to their previous employer.
  • If something confidential comes up anyway, don't use it. SCIP advises reporting it to your management or legal counsel.
  • Stay within the law. Getting a password to a competitor's system without authorization is illegal.

SCIP notes its guidance is not legal advice; for a specific situation, ask a lawyer.

Fine to askDo not ask
How buyers in this market usually compare vendorsCustomer names or customer lists
Which kinds of customers are hard to serve, in generalInternal pricing rules, discounts or contract terms
What usually goes wrong during rolloutWin rates, revenue or other internal numbers
How the market has changed over the yearsUnreleased products or plans
What they would look for as a buyer todayAnything they say they cannot discuss

Open the call with a short statement like this:

Before we start: I run a company that competes with your former employer. I'm not looking for anything confidential, so no customer names, internal numbers, pricing rules or plans. If a question gets close to that, say so and we'll skip it.

If they decline a question, move on. What to do when an expert cannot share information covers that moment.

5. Turn the research into decisions you can name

Write one short section per competitor: who chooses them and why, where buyers say they fall short and which buyers you won't chase. Mark each point's source: public material, buyer interviews or a former employee's general view. A claim with a single source is a lead to check, not a finding.

Then write down what it changes. In the example, you might learn that both software competitors focus on larger firms and that small firms leave them because setup takes weeks. That points you toward the spreadsheet users, fast setup and a price small firms can approve on their own.

Your next step

List the alternatives your last five buyers considered, including the non-software ones. Pick the one you lose to most and schedule three conversations with people who chose it.

When those people are outside your network, describe them, such as "operations managers at commercial cleaning companies" or "former account executives at facilities software vendors," and Instant Expert finds people who match. You review them and approve the request before anything goes out. Say who you are and put your no-confidential-information line in the note too, so it is settled before the call. The directory pages for operations professionals in facilities management and sales professionals in facilities management are one place to start.

Former employees of a competitor see your note and the offer before agreeing, can decline without explaining, and don't need an account to book. If they take the call, they're paid 24 hours after it, by direct deposit, a gift card or a donation to a charity they pick. The offer is what they receive and our fee is added on top for you: a $150 offer costs $188.