Porter's five forces: who keeps an industry's profit (and how to check)

Porter's five forces in plain English, a worked example, and the interview questions that tell you whether each force is really as strong as you think.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 6 min read

Porter's five forces is a framework for one question: who gets to keep the money an industry makes? It names five pressures on profit (rivalry among existing competitors, buyer power, supplier power, the threat of new entrants and the threat of substitutes), and the strongest ones show you where the profit leaks out.

Michael Porter introduced the forces in a 1979 Harvard Business Review article, "How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy," and restated and extended them in 2008 in "The Five Competitive Forces That Shape Strategy". Porter argues that managers define competition too narrowly, as only today's direct rivals, when customers, suppliers, would-be entrants and substitutes all compete for the same value. The article also explains why a fast-growing industry is not always a profitable one. (Busy and profitable are different things.)

The framework is easy to fill in from memory, which is its biggest weakness. This post shows how to test every rating with interviews.

The five forces in one minute

What drives each force, per Harvard Business School's Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness:

  • Threat of new entrants. Newcomers add capacity and push prices down. The threat depends on barriers such as economies of scale, the cost of building a brand, access to distribution and government restrictions, and rises if established companies in other regions could move in.
  • Supplier power. High when there are only one or two sources of an essential input, or when switching suppliers is expensive or slow.
  • Buyer power. High when buyers are large relative to sellers, products are undifferentiated and a significant cost, and switching is cheap. Different buyer groups can have different power.
  • Threat of substitutes. A substitute meets the same need another way, like videoconferencing instead of travel or email instead of express mail. The threat is high when its price and performance trade-off is attractive and switching is cheap.
  • Rivalry. Fiercest when competitors are numerous or similar in size, growth is slow, fixed costs and exit barriers are high, and rivals are committed to the business.

Industry structure also changes over time, through new technology, regulation, or a competitor's new pricing or distribution. Date your analysis and redo it when one of those happens.

A worked example: commercial recycling pickup

Here is a made-up example. Say you are weighing a company that collects cardboard and mixed recycling from businesses in one mid-sized metro area. Every detail and rating is hypothetical, and each rating is a guess to test.

ForceHypothesis for this exampleInitial rating
BuyersGrocery chains and property managers put contracts out to bid and switch at renewalHigh
SuppliersOnly one or two sorting facilities are within a practical haul, so they set the price paid per tonHigh
New entrantsA used truck and a permit get a small operator started; neighboring haulers could expandMedium
SubstitutesLarge grocery stores may bale cardboard on site and sell it directlyMedium for large accounts
RivalryA few similar-sized haulers with expensive trucks that must stay busy, so price cuts are commonHigh

The buyer row is worth some arithmetic. Say a hauler has 200 business accounts and the three largest grocery chains make up 40% of revenue. If one chain moves its contract to a rival at renewal, the hauler loses roughly 13% of revenue at once (40% ÷ 3, assuming the chains are similar in size). The trucks and drivers cost the same whether they are full or not.

So the attractive part of this industry is probably the smaller accounts that never run a formal bid. The grocery chains look like the prize. They are also the customers best placed to walk away.

Test each force with interviews, not memory

Desk research gives you the questions. People in the industry tell you which answers are true here. For each force, ask the people who feel it:

ForceWhom to askQuestions to ask
BuyersFacility managers at grocery stores, property managersHow did you choose your current hauler? When did you last change, and why?
SuppliersSales or operations staff at sorting facilitiesHow is the price per ton set? Do all haulers get the same terms?
New entrantsOwners of small haulers, haulers in neighboring metrosWhat did it take to start? What would stop you expanding into this area?
SubstitutesStore operations managersHave you looked at baling cardboard yourselves? What stopped you?
RivalryFormer managers or sales reps at local haulersHow do haulers win business from each other? Who starts the price cuts?

Three habits make these calls useful:

  • Ask about recent events, not opinions. "When did you last change haulers?" beats "Is switching easy?" Switching always sounds easy until someone has to do it.
  • Count agreement. If four of five facility managers describe a formal bid at every renewal, buyer power is high. If one does, you may have found one unusual account.
  • Stay clear of confidential information. The SCIP Code of Ethics says to disclose who you are before every interview and to tell former employees up front that you do not want confidential information. Competitive intelligence covers the rules.

Then change every rating the evidence did not support. In the example, you might learn that sorting facilities publish a price per ton tied to a commodity index (supplier power high, but predictable) and that small businesses rarely switch unless service fails. That points toward small accounts and reliable service.

Three ways to get it wrong

  • Drawing the industry boundary in the wrong place. Every force then gets rated against the wrong companies. Mapping your competitors covers drawing the boundary by what buyers would switch to.
  • Filling the table from memory. Each rating should point to a filing, a price list or a count of interviews.
  • Treating it as a score. The point is to see where the profit goes and where a company could face weaker pressure, not to add up five ratings.

Your next step

Write one line per force: your hypothesis and the evidence you have today. Circle the two weakest lines and schedule three interviews for each with people on that side of the market.

If you do not know those people, describe them on Instant Expert, such as "facility managers at grocery chains," and review who it finds before anything is sent. Two weak forces at three interviews each is six calls. Say you offer each person $100 for 30 minutes: with our fee on top (20% of what you pay) each call costs you $125, charged only if they book, so the most the six can cost is $750. They have 7 days to pick a time, and declines cost nothing.

A narrow factual question doesn't need a call. "How does your facility set the price per ton for haulers?" can go to sorting facility staff as a request for a written or voice answer, charged when the answer arrives. Keep calls for the buyer and rivalry questions, where the follow-ups matter. The directory pages for procurement professionals in recycling and operations professionals in waste management are one place to start.