Competitive landscape: ask where buyers go if prices rise 5%, then draw the map
A competitive landscape maps every option a buyer could switch to. Set the boundary with a 5% price question, group players by what buyers value, then check it.
A competitive landscape is a map of every business a buyer could reasonably choose, grouped by how they compete, with a note on who is gaining and who could enter. The hard part is the boundary, and the best way to draw it is to ask buyers where they would go if prices rose.
A competitor analysis studies a few direct rivals in depth. A landscape is wider and shallower, and it is what you need to choose a market, write an investment memo or judge whether a company you might buy has room to grow.
The example: a distributor that says it competes with the nationals
Here is a made-up example; the company, numbers and findings are hypothetical. You are an investor looking at a regional foodservice distributor that delivers groceries, paper goods and cleaning supplies to about 400 independent restaurants in one metro area. The seller says it "competes with the national distributors." You want to know who it really competes with, and what could change its position.
1. Draw the boundary by what buyers would switch to
Too broad, and the map is useless ("food"). Too narrow, and you miss the option buyers actually turn to.
U.S. antitrust agencies have written down how they handle this. The 2023 Merger Guidelines' section on market definition says a market has a product dimension and a geographic dimension, and its outer edge is set by which products buyers find reasonably interchangeable. One tool is the hypothetical monopolist test: if one company controlled every product in a candidate group, could it profitably impose a small but significant price increase? The guidelines say the agencies often use 5%. If buyers would switch to something outside the group, the group is too narrow.
Borrow the question without the legal analysis: if every supplier in this group raised prices 5%, where would buyers go? A restaurant owner might say "to the cash-and-carry warehouse store," so the warehouse store goes on the map.
The guidelines also list practical signs of a separate market, such as industry recognition, distinct customers, distinct prices and specialized vendors. For geography they name transportation costs, regulation and local service availability. For a distributor that delivers daily, the delivery radius is the geography.
2. List the players from four directions, because each one misses some
- Buyers. Ask five or six what they buy, from whom and what they used before. This finds the options no industry report lists.
- Industry classification. The Census Bureau's NAICS is the standard federal agencies use to classify businesses, and its keyword search shows which codes cover your market. The SBA's competitive analysis guidance also points to NAICS and Census Business Builder as free starting points.
- Public filings. The SEC's EDGAR full-text search covers electronic filings since 2001. Search a phrase your market uses and see which public companies mention it. In a 10-K, Item 1 describes the business and may cover its competition, and Item 1A lists its main risks.
- Suppliers and trade shows. Manufacturers know every distributor that carries their products. Exhibitor lists show who is trying to sell in the market.
The SBA notes that several industries may compete to serve the same market, so keep indirect options: in the example, warehouse stores, online restaurant supply retailers and specialty suppliers that sell only produce or only meat.
3. Group them on what buyers said, not on a template
A long list is not a map yet. Pick two or three dimensions buyers named when they explained their choices, and place each player. A table is easier to update than a chart.
| Group | Examples in the market | Range carried | How they deliver | Who they serve best |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| National broadline distributors | 2 national companies | Very broad | Scheduled trucks, minimum orders | Chains and larger independents |
| Regional broadline distributors | The target, plus 1 rival | Broad | Scheduled trucks, lower minimums | Independents |
| Specialty distributors | About 6 produce, meat and seafood firms | Narrow, deep | Daily, flexible | Restaurants that care about one category |
| Cash-and-carry and online | 2 warehouse clubs, several websites | Broad but shallow | Buyer picks up, or parcel | Small restaurants and top-up orders |
These dimensions came from hypothetical buyer interviews; yours should come from your buyers.
4. Check the map with people who see the market from different sides
Desk research shows what companies claim. Test it:
- Restaurant owners and kitchen managers: Who do you buy from now? What would make you move volume from one group to another?
- Suppliers' sales reps: Which distributors are gaining shelf space with you, and why?
- Former staff of distributors: How do customers usually leave? Which groups compete hardest for the same restaurants? Ask about general patterns, not their former employer's customers or numbers.
- Adjacent operators: Could a delivery platform or a regional grocery chain start serving restaurants?
During a deal, check with the seller and your advisors before contacting the target's customers or staff, since the deal terms may restrict it. People at competitors and other companies in the market are usually easier to reach. Market research interviews with customers, suppliers and operators and what to do when experts disagree cover running and reconciling these conversations.
5. Write down what the map means for your decision
End with a short answer to the question that started the work. For the example:
- Where the target sits: one of two regional broadliners, serving independents with lower order minimums than the nationals.
- Who is gaining: if owners say they are moving produce to specialty firms and top-up orders to warehouse clubs, the target's share of each restaurant's spending may be shrinking even if its customer count is steady. Check this against its sales by category.
- Who could enter: national distributors lowering minimums for independents would squeeze the target directly.
- What to check in diligence: revenue per restaurant over time, category mix, and how many customers also buy from specialty firms.
Date the map and list its sources. An undated map gets reused long after it stops being true (usually in someone else's slide deck).
Your next step
Write one sentence defining the market by product and geography. Then ask five buyers where they would go if every option in it got 5% more expensive, and add whatever they name before you start grouping.
If you need to talk to buyers or operators you don't know, and the deal terms from step 4 allow it, describe them to Instant Expert, such as "owners of independent restaurants in Denver" or "former sales reps at foodservice distributors." The 5% question works as a written request: each owner answers in text or by voice note on their own time. Then send a 30-minute call request to the owners whose answers surprise you. You set what each person receives, at least $5, our fee is added on top, and you're charged only when someone answers or books. The directory pages for sales professionals in food distribution and operations professionals in food distribution are one place to start.