PESTLE analysis is easy to fill in and hard to use. Here is how to tie it to a decision

A PESTLE analysis is useful only when each factor is tied to a decision. A template, a made-up EV charging example and whom to interview for each factor.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 7 min read

A PESTLE analysis is only useful when every factor is tied to a decision. It lists the political, economic, social, technological, legal and environmental factors outside an organization that could affect one. The CIPD, a UK-based professional body for people professionals, calls it a broad fact-finding exercise about external factors that helps an organization make the most of opportunities and reduce threats (CIPD: PESTLE analysis).

It grew out of PEST, a framework for scanning the business environment that Wikipedia's summary credits to Francis Aguilar in 1967. PESTLE adds legal and environmental factors (Wikipedia: PEST analysis).

The usual failure is a tidy list linked to nothing (six full boxes and no decision). Wikipedia's summary quotes the warning that "it is all too easy to produce lists of factors," while understanding their cause and effect on the business is harder. The CIPD adds deciding on too little data, collecting so much that nothing gets decided, and assumptions that later prove wrong.

PESTLE covers the world outside one industry

Porter's five forces covers the structure of one industry. A SWOT analysis combines your internal strengths and weaknesses with external opportunities and threats, and a PESTLE often supplies the external half. The CIPD suggests using PESTLE alongside SWOT, Porter's five forces, competitor analysis or scenario planning.

1. Use a template with evidence beside every factor

The CIPD's factsheet gives examples for each factor. Political: tax policy, trade restrictions, tariffs and political stability. Economic: growth, interest, exchange, inflation and wage rates, and credit availability. Social: cultural norms, population growth, age distribution and attitudes. Technological: new technologies and the rate of change. Legal: changes to legislation on employment, imports and exports, and taxation. Environmental: sustainability, ethical sourcing and emergencies.

Use one row per factor:

FactorWhat could changeHow it would change our decisionEvidence nowWho could confirm or reject itLikelihood and impact
Political
Economic
Social
Technological
Legal
Environmental

The last three columns turn a list into a plan.

2. Write a first draft from public sources

Here is a made-up example: the company, its plans and every finding below are invented. It runs 40 fast-charging sites in one state and is deciding whether to build 15 more in a neighboring state over the next two years. The leadership team's first draft:

FactorHypothesisStarting evidence
PoliticalPublic funding could cover part of the cost of new sites, but programs can change with budgetsThe Department of Energy's Alternative Fuels Data Center (AFDC) keeps a database of federal, state and utility incentives
EconomicElectricity costs and how often chargers are used decide whether a site makes moneyThe neighboring state's utility rate filings
SocialDemand depends on how many drivers nearby rely on public chargingThe AFDC notes that most EV owners do most of their charging at home
TechnologicalNew sites may need more than one connector typeThe AFDC says SAE International is standardizing the J3400 connector based on Tesla's NACS design, and that several automakers have announced adopting it
LegalPermits and utility connection rules set the build scheduleState permitting rules and utility interconnection procedures
EnvironmentalWeather and flood risk can take sites offlineFlood maps and the company's own outage records

Sources: AFDC Station Locator, AFDC: EV charging stations. The Station Locator also shows public and private stations with counts by state, so the team can count existing fast chargers in the target state first. The AFDC's charging page names federal programs, such as the National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure Formula Program, as sources of fast-charging funding. Check each program's current status instead of assuming it.

Every row is still a guess until people who do the work tell you which answers hold in this market.

3. Test each factor with someone who does the work

FactorWhom to askQuestions
PoliticalState energy office staff, regulatory consultants, former agency staffWhich programs funded charging here in the last two years, and how were awards decided?
EconomicUtility account managers who serve charging sites, operators of existing stationsIn a slow month, how much of a site's electricity bill comes from peak-demand charges?
SocialFleet managers, managers of stores or restaurants that host chargersWhere do your drivers or customers charge now?
TechnologicalCharging network operations managers, field service leadsWhich connectors are you installing on new sites, and why?
LegalRegulatory consultants, utility interconnection specialistsHow long did your last connection take from application to power-on, and what delayed it?
EnvironmentalSite developers, operations managersWhich sites lost the most uptime to weather, and what did you change afterward?

For legal and political factors, separate what the rule says from how it works. Read the text yourself: federal rules and proposed rules appear in the Federal Register. Then ask a regulatory expert how it is applied and how long approvals actually take, which is rarely written down.

  • Ask about recent events. "How long did your last interconnection take?" beats "Is interconnection slow?"
  • Count agreement. If four of five operators name the same delay, it belongs in the analysis. If one does, keep asking.
  • Tie each answer to the decision. After every call, update the "How it would change our decision" column.

In the example, the team might learn from three operators and two utility specialists that connection timelines, more than funding, set the schedule, and that peak-demand charges make low-traffic sites lose money in year one. The decision could then become: apply for utility connections at the five strongest locations now, and wait on the other ten until the first five show their usage.

4. Rate each factor, then put a date on the page

The CIPD's steps finish by rating each item by risk, identifying options, sharing findings with decision makers and deciding what to act on and what to monitor. A simple version: rate each factor high, medium or low for likelihood and for impact, act on anything high on both, and set a date to check the rest.

The CIPD also says a PESTLE needs repeating regularly to be useful. Write the date at the top, so nobody presents last year's version as news.

5. Avoid the four usual mistakes

  • No decision at the top. Without one, every factor looks equally important.
  • Filling it in from memory. Each row should cite a document, a dataset or interviews.
  • Treating it as a forecast. The CIPD warns that the pace of change makes future developments hard to anticipate. A PESTLE shows what to watch.
  • Asking regulators' former staff for inside information. Ask how processes work in general, never about pending decisions or confidential cases. What to do when an expert cannot share confidential information covers the boundary.

Your next step

Write the decision at the top of the template. For each letter, add one factor that could change it and the role of someone who would know. Book two interviews for the two factors you know least about.

Instant Expert can find people who match a description you write, such as "network operations managers at EV fast-charging companies" or "interconnection specialists at electric utilities." You review who it finds, it sends your invitations, and you pay only for calls that get booked. The directory pages for EV charging network operations experts and utility interconnection queue experts are one place to start.