Target market analysis: why the biggest market is often the wrong one to pick first

Target market analysis picks one market to sell to first. Set criteria, count each market with public data, fill the gaps with interviews, then test the choice.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 5 min read

Target market analysis should end with one market to sell to first, and the biggest candidate is often not it. Compare a few candidates on the same questions: how many buyers there are, who pays, how easy they are to reach, how strongly they feel the problem and what they use today. Public data answers the counting questions. Conversations answer the rest, and those usually decide.

To describe the people inside a market you have already chosen, see target audience research. How to choose your first customer segment covers defining segments by a shared problem, a good step before this one.

The example: one reminder tool, three kinds of clinic

Here is a made-up example: the product and the interview findings are hypothetical, and the employment figures come from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. You built a tool that sends appointment reminders and "you're due for a checkup" messages for small clinics. It could fit dental practices, optometry practices or veterinary clinics, and you can only afford integrations and marketing for one.

1. Write the criteria before you look at data

Decide what makes a market attractive first, so the numbers don't pick the criteria for you. The SBA's market research guide lists useful ones: demand, market size, economic indicators, location, market saturation and what customers pay for alternatives. For a business product, add who signs off and how you would reach them.

For the clinic example:

  1. How many practices could buy it.
  2. Who decides, and whether they can say yes without a head office.
  3. How much a missed or late appointment costs the practice.
  4. What they use for reminders today, and how satisfied they are.
  5. Whether there is a practical channel to reach them, such as associations, conferences or software marketplaces.

2. Count each market with public data

The BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook gives jobs in each profession and the industries that employ them. Multiply the two for a rough count of practitioners in practice offices, which is closer to your buyer than the headline figure. BLS lists self-employed practitioners separately, so this count leaves them out.

Candidate marketJobs in 2025Share in the core practice industryRough count in practices
Dentists161,40078% in offices of dentistsabout 125,900
Veterinarians91,10083% in veterinary servicesabout 75,600
Optometrists45,10061% in offices of optometristsabout 27,500

Two cautions. First, these count practitioners, and a reminder tool is bought per practice. For practice counts, use the Census Bureau's County Business Patterns, which reports establishments with paid employees by industry, employment size and county.

Second, the industry split hints at how the market buys. BLS reports that 13% of optometrists work in retail trade, where purchasing is probably central, so that part is likely a different sale.

Size is one criterion. The largest market often has the most competitors and the most built-in alternatives.

3. Answer the rest in conversations

Data can't tell you what a missed appointment costs, what the practice uses now or who approves the purchase. Ask five or six practice managers or owners in each market about a recent, specific event:

Tell me about the last week you had several no-shows. What happened, what did it cost you, and what did you do about it?

Suppose the interviews found this (still hypothetical):

  • Dental: most practices already send reminders through their practice-management software and see little reason to add a tool.
  • Veterinary: vaccine and annual checkup reminders bring in a lot of revenue, and several managers complained about their current setup.
  • Optometry: independent practices were interested, but a large share of the market sits inside retail chains.

Market research interviews with customers, suppliers and operators covers who else to talk to, such as the software vendors and consultants who sell to these practices.

4. Compare the markets in one table

Mark where each rating comes from.

CriterionDentalVeterinaryOptometryEvidence
Number of potential buyersLargestMiddleSmallestBLS; check with County Business Patterns
Decision maker can say yes aloneOftenOftenMixed: independents yes, retail noInterviews
Cost of a missed appointmentMediumHighMediumInterviews
Satisfaction with current toolHighLowMediumInterviews
Channel to reach themSeveralSeveralFewerInterviews and desk research

Here veterinary clinics win despite being the middle market by size: the pain is stronger and fewer practices like what they have. Dental is bigger but already served. That pattern is common, which is why you finish the interviews before choosing.

5. Test the choice with a result you set in advance

Before committing, write down what would change your mind: "If we contact 50 veterinary clinics in one state and fewer than five agree to a two-week trial, we revisit the choice." A real response to a real offer beats any rating table.

Your next step

List your candidate markets and the five criteria you will judge them on. Fill in the public counts in an afternoon, then schedule five conversations in each market.

When you don't know anyone in a candidate market, Instant Expert can find people who match a description you write, such as "practice managers at independent veterinary clinics." You review who it finds, it sends your invitations, and you pay only for calls that get booked. The directory pages for operations professionals in veterinary services and operations professionals in dental services are one place to start.