Market validation: stop counting compliments and ask for a paid pilot
Market validation is proof buyers will give something up for your idea. Set pass or fail criteria, run problem interviews and expert calls, then ask for a pilot.
Market validation is evidence, collected before you build much, that a specific group of buyers has a problem, already spends time or money on it, and will commit to your fix. The strongest proof is something they give up: money, time, or their standing with colleagues when they introduce you. Compliments and "I would definitely use that" don't count, because people say them to be polite.
If you are still working out what to research and in what order, market research to start a business covers that. This page covers the validation step itself.
The example: an app that tracks restaurant food waste
Here is a made-up example used throughout the page. You want to build an app where kitchen staff log the food they throw away, so owners can order less of it. You have worked in restaurants and believe waste is expensive, but you don't know whether owners will pay to track it.
1. Write your pass and fail criteria before the first conversation
Without written criteria, every result starts to look encouraging. (Even "my cousin said it's neat.") For the restaurant app, the criteria might be:
- Most owners we interview can describe a recent week when they threw away food they later had to reorder.
- Owners, as well as chefs, say waste is a cost they watch.
- At least 3 of the first 20 restaurants agree to a paid 60-day pilot at our proposed price.
These numbers are examples, not a standard. Pick thresholds that would justify the time you are about to spend, and don't lower them after the results come in.
2. Rank evidence by what it cost the buyer
| Evidence | What it shows | Strength |
|---|---|---|
| "Great idea," "I'd use that" | Politeness | Weak |
| A detailed story about a recent incident | The problem happens | Moderate |
| Money or time already spent on a workaround | The problem costs something | Stronger |
| A second meeting, an introduction to the decision maker, or data shared | It is a priority for them | Stronger |
| A deposit, pre-order, paid pilot or signed letter of intent | They will pay | Strongest before launch |
Rob Fitzpatrick's The Mom Test is a short book on exactly this problem: how to learn whether your business is a good idea "when everyone is lying to you," including how to avoid biased feedback and tell whether someone will actually buy.
3. Ask buyers about the last time it happened
Start with the people who would use and pay for the product, and ask about a recent event instead of your idea:
Tell me about the last time you threw out food you had ordered that week. What was it, how did you notice, and what did you change afterward?
Listen for specifics: what was thrown away, what it cost, who noticed and whether anything changed. An owner who can't remember a recent example is telling you something.
How many conversations you need depends on how clear the pattern is. NSF's I-Corps program, which trains research teams to judge a technology's commercial potential, requires a minimum of 100 potential customer interviews during its seven-week program. You don't need 100 to spot a clear no, but it shows the scale a structured program expects. How many customer interviews do you need covers when to stop, and problem vs. solution interviews covers when to start showing your idea.
4. Call experts for what buyers can't see
Owners know their own kitchens, but usually can't tell you how food distributors price and deliver, which software restaurants already pay for, or why earlier waste-tracking products did or didn't stick. People who see many restaurants at once can: a distributor's sales rep, a purchasing manager at a restaurant group, someone who used to sell restaurant software.
Treat what they say as leads to check with owners. Market research interviews with customers, suppliers and operators explains how to combine those views. If someone used to work for a competitor, say up front that you don't want confidential information. What to do when an expert cannot share confidential information covers the moment they can't answer.
5. Ask for a commitment
Interviews tell you the problem is real. A commitment tells you the market will pay:
- Paid pilot: a short, paid trial with a clear end date and success measure, often the most natural option for businesses.
- Letter of intent: a signed statement that the buyer plans to purchase at a stated price if the product does what you describe. Weaker than money, stronger than a verbal yes.
- Pre-order or deposit: money up front for something you will deliver later.
- Doing it by hand first: Paul Graham's Do Things that Don't Scale describes doing by hand what you plan to automate later. That can let you charge for the result before the software exists. For the restaurant app, you could count waste yourself for a few weeks and deliver a weekly report. (Bring gloves.)
Tell buyers the product isn't finished, and put the delivery date and refund terms in writing.
If you take pre-orders for physical goods by mail, phone or online in the U.S., the FTC's Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule requires a reasonable basis for the shipping time you state, or for shipping within 30 days if you state none. If you can't ship on time, you must ask the buyer to agree to the delay, and if you won't ship at all, cancel and promptly refund them. The rule doesn't cover services, and other rules may apply to them and to software. This is general information, not legal advice, so check what applies to you.
6. Hold the results against the criteria you wrote first
- Pass: build the smallest version that serves the customers who committed, and keep talking to them.
- Mixed: look for a sub-group that passed. Perhaps multi-location restaurant groups committed and single restaurants didn't. Rewrite the criteria for that group and test again.
- Fail: change the segment or the problem, or stop. A clear no after a few weeks costs far less than a product nobody pays for.
Your next step
Write three pass-or-fail criteria for your idea today, including one that requires a commitment. Then book the first five problem interviews.
If the buyers or industry people you need are outside your network, describe them to Instant Expert, such as "owners of independent restaurants with two to five locations" or "sales reps at food distributors." Offers are per person for a 15, 30, 45 or 60 minute call, with our fee added on top (a $100 offer costs you $125) and charged at booking, never for an ignored invitation. Keep one thing straight when you score the results: a paid call is evidence about the problem, not about demand. An owner who accepts $100 to talk has told you nothing about whether they would pay you, so the commitment in step 5 still has to come separately. The directory pages for procurement professionals in restaurants and sales professionals in food distribution are one place to start.