Focus group research is good for words and bad for behavior. Here is when to use it

Use focus group research to hear how similar people react and talk about a topic together. Use one-on-one interviews to learn what each person actually did.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 5 min read

Focus group research is the right tool for hearing how people react to something and the words they use with each other. It is the wrong tool for learning what one person actually did. A focus group is a moderated discussion of one topic among a small group of similar people. For real decisions, or anything people won't say in front of peers, interview them one at a time.

University of Wisconsin-Extension says focus groups are "focused" in two ways: the participants are similar in some way, and the discussion follows a focused set of questions. Because participants respond to each other, a group produces different information than the same people would alone (Quick Tips: Focus Group Interviews). The goal is a range of opinions, not consensus.

Groups are good at reactions and shared vocabulary

  • Many reactions at once. Seven people reacting to the same concept, message or name in 90 minutes.
  • Shared language that helps with positioning and with wording a later survey.
  • Needs you didn't know to ask about. In The Use and Misuse of Focus Groups, Jakob Nielsen says the proper role of focus groups in product development is to discover what users want. The article describes running one with system administrators at Sun to learn how they wanted large documentation files distributed across servers, questions a usability test would never have raised.
  • Group dynamics and organizational issues, which Nielsen notes you can observe directly.
  • Work that spans days or weeks, which would be expensive to watch.

Groups mislead you about behavior

  • Say versus do. Nielsen's central warning is that focus groups capture what people say they do, not how they behave. Nielsen recommends always adding direct observation of one user at a time.
  • Usability. Watching a demo is different from using a product. Nielsen calls focus groups "a rather poor method for evaluating interface usability."
  • Wanting versus needing. People may want one thing and need another. Nielsen suggests concrete examples or prototypes to reduce this.
  • The group changes the answer. Richard Krueger's analysis guidance notes participants sometimes change or even reverse their positions after hearing others (Designing and Conducting Focus Group Interviews). So a group's conclusion is not each person's view.
  • One session is not enough. Nielsen and Krueger both recommend more than one group, because any single discussion can be sidetracked or unrepresentative. (Every group has the one person with strong views about the logo.)

Choose by the question you are asking

Your questionBetter fitWhy
How did this customer choose their current vendor?One-on-one interviewYou need one person's sequence of events and who else was involved
What words do buyers use for this problem?Focus groupPeople talking to each other surface shared vocabulary
Which of three product names confuses people?Focus group, then a survey to countQuick reactions from many people; measure later
Can people complete a task with the prototype?Usability testOnly watching one person at a time shows this
How do senior buyers at competing companies decide?One-on-one interviewThey are unlikely to discuss suppliers, budgets or internal politics in front of competitors
What do members value most about a shared program?Focus groupA common experience people can build on together

The senior-buyers row is our judgment, not a finding from the sources. When participants work for competitors, or the topic touches budgets, expect less candor in a group, and expect a scheduling puzzle when you try to get several senior people into one room.

A worked example: interviews first, then groups

Here is a made-up example. You sell ingredients to independent restaurants and are considering a new ordering service. You have two questions.

First, how does each kitchen decide what to order from which supplier? That is a sequence of decisions by one or two people, with details about prices and relationships, so it calls for one-on-one interviews, perhaps five or six. Qualitative market research walks through a similar case.

Second, how do chefs and owners react to a short description of the service? That is a group question. Run two groups of six or seven, one of chefs and one of owners, since Krueger recommends putting similar people together.

Interviews first give the groups better material: you can describe the service in terms kitchens already use. A group first also works when you don't know which topics matter, if you follow up with individual interviews.

Keep groups small for business audiences

Sources differ on size. Krueger suggests five to ten participants, with six to eight preferred. Nielsen describes six to nine users for about two hours. UW-Extension says eight to 12 participants for one to two hours. For business audiences, the smaller end is easier to recruit and gives everyone time to speak.

A group needs a skilled moderator and ideally a note-taker. Focus group questions covers the question route and moderation.

There is a middle option. GOV.UK's interview guidance notes you can interview people in pairs or small groups when they use a service together, such as team members on the same tasks (Using in-depth interviews). For a B2B product used by a small team, a joint interview with the people who share the workflow can show handoffs that neither a big group nor a single interview would.

Your next step

Write your main research question on one line. If it asks what someone did or decided, plan one-on-one interviews with customer interviews as your guide. If it asks how similar people react to or talk about something, plan at least two focus groups. If it asks how many people think something, interviews vs. surveys covers when to count.

Either way, you need people who do the job. Instant Expert sends paid invitations for one-on-one calls or written answers, not group sessions, so it fits the interview side of this choice. Describe the people, such as "chefs who order for independent restaurants," pick a 15, 30, 45 or 60 minute call, and set what each person receives, with our fee added on top and charged once they book. You can add teammates to your side of the call as guests, so a moderator and a note-taker can both hear the same interview. The procurement professionals in restaurants directory page is one place to start.