A due diligence checklist with the workstream most lists skip: expert calls
A due diligence checklist by workstream (financial, legal, commercial, technology, people, operations), plus outside expert calls that test the seller's claims.
A due diligence checklist should test what the seller claims, and documents only test part of it. The usual due diligence checklist splits the review into workstreams (financial, legal, commercial, technology, people and operations), each with an owner, a document request list and questions to answer before you sign. This one adds outside expert calls, because customers, former customers and industry operators can test claims a data room cannot.
This is a planning list, not legal, tax or accounting advice. The SBA suggests buyers consider an attorney and an accountant, and they should own the legal, tax and financial workstreams. SBA: Plan your business
A made-up deal: buying an automation integrator
Here is a hypothetical example. You are buying a 40-person company that installs factory automation systems for mid-sized manufacturers. The seller says revenue is spread across many customers, the backlog is strong and the two founders who run the largest accounts will stay for two years. Each claim belongs to a different workstream and needs different evidence.
Spend your time on what could change the price
Vendor due diligence guidance from U.S. banking regulators makes two points that carry over to acquisitions. Depth should match the risk and complexity of the relationship. And when you cannot get information you asked for, write down the gap, understand the risk it leaves and decide how to cover it. Interagency Guidance on Third-Party Relationships
Keep one tracker with a row per item: owner, date requested, date received, finding and open question. (One tracker. A spreadsheet per advisor is how a lease goes unread.)
The checklist
Financial
- Recent years' income statements, balance sheets, cash flow statements and tax returns
- Revenue by customer, to test how concentrated it is
- Backlog and signed contracts against revenue actually recognized
- Debts, leases and other obligations that stay with the business
- How the price was set. The SBA lists several valuation methods, including capitalized earnings, excess earnings, cash flow, tangible assets and the value of specific intangible assets. SBA
Legal and regulatory
- Customer, supplier and employment contracts, including change-of-control clauses
- Leases, licenses and permits, and whether they transfer
- Zoning and, if real property is included, environmental review (both on the SBA's list for buyers of an existing business)
- Pending or threatened litigation
- Ownership of intellectual property and software
- Sanctions screening of the company and its owners. OFAC's Sanctions List Service includes a search tool for the SDN List and the consolidated non-SDN lists.
- Whether the deal needs a premerger filing. Under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act, parties to certain larger transactions must notify the FTC and the Justice Department and wait before closing. FTC Premerger Notification Program Your attorney will check whether it applies.
Commercial
- Market size and growth, position against alternatives, and whether customers stay and spend more. Commercial due diligence covers scope and questions.
Technology
- Systems, code, security, open-source licenses and the people who maintain them. See the technology due diligence checklist.
People
- Organization chart, key people and what happens if one leaves
- Compensation, open disputes and retention agreements
- Who holds customer relationships. In the example, the founders do, so hear from those customers directly.
Operations and suppliers
- Key suppliers and any single point of failure
- Insurance coverage
- For outsourced services the business depends on, the questions in vendor due diligence
Deal documents
The SBA lists documents an attorney and accountant typically help create and evaluate: letter of intent, confidentiality agreement, contracts and leases, financial statements, tax returns, sales agreement and purchase price adjustment. SBA
Give expert calls their own workstream and owner
Documents show what the company says. Outside calls show whether customers and the market agree. Give the calls an owner and a tracker so they happen early enough to change your questions.
- List the claims to test. In the example: "revenue is spread out," "customers come back for new projects" and "the founders' relationships will transfer."
- Pick roles, not names. Current customers you choose, one or two former customers, plant or engineering managers who used a competing integrator, and a former industry project manager.
- Set limits in the invitation. Say the topic, and that you won't ask for a current employer's confidential information.
- Run short calls. Thirty minutes usually covers one topic. Ask what people did, not what they predict.
- Log findings against the claims. Record who said what, so a seller-introduced reference counts differently from a customer you found.
Check the terms of any call source. GLG, for example, says its experts sign terms agreeing not to share confidential or material non-public information, and that employed experts may not take part in projects about their own employer. GLG compliance
For the basics, see how to prepare for an expert interview and how to choose the right expert.
End with a list of what you could not verify
List every item you could not confirm and why: the seller would not share it, it did not exist or you ran out of time. For each, decide whether to lower the price, add protection in the purchase agreement or accept the risk. This list is often more useful to your attorney than the items that checked out.
Your next step
Copy the workstreams into a tracker, give each an owner, and put the three claims the price depends on most at the top of the expert-call workstream.
Instant Expert finds people outside your network who match a description, such as "plant engineering managers at mid-sized manufacturers who have hired an automation integrator." You review who it finds, it sends your invitations, and you pay only for calls that get booked. The directory pages for operations professionals in industrial automation and sales professionals in industrial automation are a place to start.