Advisory board: start with your gaps, and expect smaller grants than the templates suggest
Build a startup advisory board from the gaps in your team, trial each advisor on real work first, and set equity with the FAST template and Carta's lower medians.
Build a startup advisory board from the gaps in your founding team, and give nobody equity until they have helped on a small piece of real work. An advisory board is a small group of experienced people who give a company advice, introductions and occasional help, with no authority to run it. At a startup it is usually a handful of individual advisors, each with a short agreement and a small equity grant, called when a question lands in their area.
Published templates and data give a reasonable range for what to offer. The typical grant is smaller than the templates suggest.
The advisory board advises; the board of directors decides
A board of directors is the company's formal governing body, and decisions such as equity grants need its approval. Carta's guide to advisory shares notes that even a grant to an advisor needs formal board approval: the directors approve, the advisors advise (Carta).
So an advisory board is easy to change: add an advisor for a new market, and let an agreement lapse when their area stops mattering.
1. Give each advisor a job before you look for them
List the two or three questions the team keeps getting stuck on, and describe who could answer each from experience. Typical gaps:
- How customers buy. Someone who has worked inside the kind of organization you sell to, and knows who approves a purchase.
- A specialist area. Regulation, a technical standard, or a supply chain the team has never worked in.
- A first hire or first channel. Someone who has hired the first salesperson, or built the first partner program, at a company like yours.
- Fundraising in your sector. Someone investors in your market already know.
Skip people chosen for their title. The Founder Institute, which publishes the FAST advisor template, says a well-known name or domain expertise does not mean someone will be a good advisor (FAST Agreement).
Here is a made-up example. Two engineers are building scheduling and reminder software for independent veterinary clinics. They know the product side well and have three gaps:
- How a clinic owner or practice manager decides to switch software.
- Which practice management systems clinics already run, and what integrating with them involves.
- How to hire and pay a first salesperson who sells to clinics.
That gives three advisor profiles: a former practice manager, someone who has sold software to veterinary clinics, and a sales leader who has built a small team from scratch. Profiles are not advisors yet. The founders still have to find out which candidates are useful in practice.
2. Trial every candidate on a small piece of real work
The FAST page lays out a sequence many founders follow (FAST Agreement):
- List 10 to 15 target advisors.
- Find people you have in common and ask for an introduction.
- Send a five-sentence introduction and ask for a call or a coffee.
- If the conversation goes well, make a small request to test the working relationship.
- If that works, invite them to engage more formally, without discussing compensation yet.
- If they agree, send the agreement.
The Founder Institute recommends working together for at least a month, and at least 8 hours, before discussing the agreement. Step 4 matters most. Ask for something with a visible result, such as a review of your pricing page or introductions to two clinic owners.
3. Pay in equity, and expect the typical grant to be small
Startup advisors are commonly paid in equity, usually stock options or restricted stock, vesting over time.
The FAST template sets grants by company stage and by how much the advisor does (FAST Agreement):
| Engagement | Pre-seed | Seed | Series A |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard: monthly meetings | 0.50% | 0.25% | 0.10% |
| Expert: adds contacts and projects | 1.00% | 0.75% | 0.50% |
FAST's worked example has an expert-level pre-seed advisor earning 1% vesting over two years, with a three-month cliff so an unproductive relationship can end before any equity vests. Its FAQ adds that a technology startup often reserves around 5% of equity for all its advisors, and that FAST is not meant for project consulting or work-for-hire.
Carta's data comes in lower. In the first half of 2024 the median advisor grant was 0.21% of fully diluted shares at pre-seed companies, 0.12% at seed and 0.05% at Series A, and only 10% of pre-seed advisors received 1% or more (Carta). Treat FAST as an upper guide for an unusually involved advisor and Carta as a picture of what is typical.
Carta says vesting is often two years, monthly, sometimes with a three-month cliff, because advisors tend to deliver most of their value early.
Back to the made-up veterinary software company. Say it has 10,000,000 fully diluted shares and offers a seed-stage standard grant of 0.25%. That is 25,000 shares. Vesting monthly over 24 months, about 1,042 shares vest each month. If the advisor stops after six months, about 6,250 shares have vested.
Before promising equity, Carta suggests asking whether the advisor would rather invest. Their own money gives them a stronger reason to help.
4. Write the agreement down
Carta lists what an advisor agreement should cover: the advisor's area of expertise and role, the expected time commitment, the exact number of shares or options, the vesting schedule including any cliff, and confidentiality and intellectual property terms. FAST is a common starting point. Carta recommends having your lawyer review any agreement and documenting board approval of the grant (Carta).
A one-off question doesn't need an advisor
An advisor makes sense when you expect to come back to the same person for months. If the veterinary founders only need to know how practice managers compare scheduling tools, two years of vesting is a heavy price for one person's answer.
A few paid calls with people who have done the job are faster, give you more than one view, and work as the small request from section 2. On Instant Expert you set what each person receives for a 15, 30, 45 or 60 minute call, and our fee is added on top: a $100 offer costs you $125, charged only if they book (how it works). The practice manager sees your note and the amount, has 7 days to pick a time, and doesn't need an account to book. Whoever gave the most useful answer is a natural advisor candidate, and you have already seen how they work.
To have someone own a function part-time, see fractional executives; for a defined project, hiring a consultant; for free ongoing support, how to find a mentor.
If you are the one being asked to advise
The Carta medians above are closer to what a typical advisor receives than the FAST table, and those shares pay off only if the company does. When a founder mostly wants your answers to a few questions, asking to be paid per conversation is a fair alternative to a two-year grant.
If a founder invites you through Instant Expert, the amount in the invitation is what you receive. You can book a time, decline, or reply with the price you want; a counteroffer above the offer goes to the founder, and their answer comes back to you in the same thread. Payment goes out 24 hours after the call, by direct deposit, a gift card, or as a donation to a charity you pick (we make the donation, and the founder pays the same either way). If the calls keep coming from the same founder, that is the moment to discuss a formal advisor role. Advisory board pay covers what advisors are paid in cash and equity.
Start from one sentence per gap
Write down your two or three biggest gaps and one sentence describing who could close each. For the veterinary founders, the first sentence is "practice managers at independent veterinary clinics who switched scheduling software in the last two years." Browse operations professionals in veterinary services and sales professionals in veterinary services, book two calls per gap, and offer an advisor role only to someone whose small request went well. How to choose the right expert for your first call helps you pick whom to speak with first.