How to write a discussion guide that sounds like a conversation (with a 45-minute template)
A discussion guide is a loose map: open questions in order, follow-ups ready. Seven steps, a timed 45-minute template, and focus group and usability versions.
A discussion guide works best as a loose map: open questions in a sensible order, with follow-ups ready for when someone says something interesting. It is what a moderator uses to run a research interview or focus group: your introduction, the questions in order, follow-up prompts, activity instructions and a checklist for the day (GOV.UK). It is also called an interview guide or topic guide, and focus group moderators sometimes call theirs a questioning route.
Nielsen Norman Group explains that a script belongs to structured interviews, while a guide can be used flexibly: the interviewer can change the order, skip questions or ask ones that aren't in it (Nielsen Norman Group). That is how you follow an unexpected answer.
Interviewing without a guide produces leading questions
NN/g names two risks of winging it. Questions made up on the spot tend to come out leading, and you fail to cover the same topics in every interview. (Everyone plans to ask about pricing every time. By session four, nobody does.)
GOV.UK adds that a guide helps several interviewers cover the same ground, lets the team review sessions together and records what you did in each round.
A discussion guide has seven parts
- Research questions at the top, so you remember what the sessions are for.
- Introduction: who you are, the purpose, the length, recording and confidentiality, and that they can skip any question.
- Warm-up questions that are easy to answer.
- Main topics, each with one or two starter questions and a few follow-ups.
- Activities, if any, such as a prototype task.
- Closing: check your summary, ask what you missed, thank them.
- Timings beside each section.
Pathfinder International's guide to in-depth interviews adds two rules worth keeping: no more than 15 main questions, and factual questions before opinion questions (Pathfinder International).
How to write one in seven steps
NN/g's process, condensed:
- Write your research questions. These are what you want to learn, not what you will ask. "How do supply chain teams decide which recalled items to pull first?" is a research question.
- Brainstorm interview questions without judging them.
- Broaden them. Replace clusters of closed questions with one open question that invites a story. "Walk me through your last workday" replaces five yes-or-no questions, which become follow-ups.
- Check coverage. Every research question needs at least one interview question that serves it.
- Put them in order. Chronological order usually suits an experience. Save reflective questions until people have recalled specific events.
- Add follow-ups and probes, such as "When did that happen?" and "Tell me more about that."
- Pilot the guide with someone like your participants, then reword and cut.
A 45-minute template you can copy
Here is a made-up example. A company building recall-management software wants to learn how hospital supply chain teams handle a product recall, from the first notice to confirming every affected item is off the shelves. Each interview runs 45 minutes by video with a supply chain manager or director.
Research questions
- Who first learns about a recall, and how?
- How does the team find where affected items are?
- Who confirms the items have been removed, and how do they know?
Introduction (3 minutes)
Thanks for making time. I'm [name] from [company]. We're learning how hospital supply chain teams handle product recalls, and I'd like to talk through one recent recall you dealt with. There are no right answers. Please leave out patient information and anything confidential to your hospital, and feel free to skip any question. With your permission I'd like to record so I can focus on listening; only our research team will hear it. Any questions before we start?
Warm-up (5 minutes)
- What does your role cover, and how long have you been in it?
- How is your supply chain team organized?
Topic 1: The most recent recall (15 minutes)
- Think of the most recent recall your team handled. How did you first hear about it?
- Follow-ups: Who told you? What did you do in the first hour? What information was missing?
- How did you work out where the affected items were?
- Follow-ups: Which systems did you check? What did you have to check by hand?
Topic 2: Confirming removal (10 minutes)
- How did you know every affected item had been removed?
- Follow-ups: Who signed off? Was anything found later?
Topic 3: Comparison (7 minutes)
- How did that recall compare with others you've handled? What made it easier or harder?
- If you could change one part of the process, what would it be, and why?
Closing (5 minutes)
- Summarize: "Let me check I have the sequence right..."
- Is there anything important about recalls that we didn't cover?
- Thank them and explain what happens next.
Facts about one real event come first; the opinion question comes last. The sections add up to exactly 45 minutes, so mark one or two questions you can drop when a topic runs long (one will).
A 30-minute customer discovery interview script shows a more detailed version for discovery calls, and qualitative research interview questions covers writing individual questions.
For a focus group, add ground rules and question types
Richard Krueger's focus group guide for the University of Minnesota adds parts specific to groups (Krueger, University of Minnesota):
- A standard introduction: welcome, a topic overview, ground rules, then the first question. Sample ground rules: no right or wrong answers, one person speaks at a time, and nobody needs to agree.
- Five types of question, in order: an opening question everyone answers in turn, an introductory question, transition questions, the key questions that matter most and ending questions.
- Questions that look back to an experience rather than forward, and none answerable with yes or no.
- A three-step close: check your summary, review the purpose and ask what was missed, then thank everyone.
Focus group questions has examples of each type.
For a usability test, swap topics for tasks
GOV.UK's guidance on moderated usability testing describes a guide with your introduction script, each task with its instructions, and a planning checklist. Good tasks set a clear, believable goal without hinting at how to complete it (GOV.UK). Usability testing covers how to write the tasks.
Six mistakes that ruin a good guide
- Too many questions. Thirty questions in 45 minutes means rushing every answer.
- Leading questions. "How frustrating is the recall process?" assumes the answer. "How did that recall go?" doesn't.
- Opinions before facts. "What would you improve?" asked before a real event is described gets a generic answer.
- Reading it word for word. Only the introduction should sound read.
- Skipping the pilot. One practice run usually exposes a confusing question.
- Never revising it. NN/g says updating the guide between interviews is fine. Note what changed so you can compare sessions.
Your next step
Write your research questions at the top of a blank page. Under each, add one question about a specific recent event and two follow-ups. Add an introduction, a close and timings, then run it once with a colleague.
If you need people to interview, Instant Expert can send paid invitations to people who match a description you write, such as "supply chain directors at hospitals." Match the call length to your guide: the template above fits a 45-minute call, one of four lengths (15, 30, 45 or 60 minutes). You set what each person receives, our fee is added on top, and you're charged only when someone books. The invitation note is the first thing they read, so reuse the one-sentence purpose from your introduction there, and save the full introduction for the call. Adjust its recording line too: the video room records the call from when you join, for attendance and disputes, so "only our research team will hear it" needs to say what your team records and that the platform keeps its own copy (recording consent). The hospital supply chain experts directory page is one place to start, and in-depth interviews covers planning the whole study.